Monday, 27 August 2018

Three Ways to Solve Resource Tracking

Resource management can be a real fucking drag.
I'm going to call out the biggest potential drags here:

Food
Light
Ammo

The trifecta of trackables. Mundane, cheap, and not that heavy. Often handwaved or forgotten.
Luckily they represent three different ways of handling resources in my game!


Prepper culture is essentially adventurers prepping for a dungeoncrawl that'll never come


But first!

Some game design theory around resource management.

Resource management has come up a fair amount lately in the OSR, which is of course what triggered this post.
DIY & Dragons has a two-parter on resource management -- Part 1 and Part 2
Followed up by Scones Alone in this post.
And followed up in turn by DIY & Dragons again in this post.

Read up if you haven't already, but I'll summarise where I'm coming from:

- I like the idea of tracking mundane resources.
- I want it to be easy.


So

There are two main ways a resource can be used up.
Drain or Use.

Drain is when they tick down over time. Usually these are the mundane things.
At the end of the day, mark off a ration. After an hour, light a new torch. Tick tick tick. They drain away.

Use is when you make the active decision to use them up. Throw oil bomb to set a thing on fire! Drink a potion to get a magic effect! Read a scroll to cast a spell! Throw torch in pit to see how deep it goes!

In Aura's words:
"This is constantly dwindled to prevent a bad thing" VS "You can choose to use this for a Cool Thing."

Resources that drain are the ones that are boring to track and easy to forget if they're left solely to the player to manage.
I've never seen a player complain that they've got to keep track of three different potions, but I had players forget to mark off rations and ammo and stuff all the time.



These Rations for RPG Races are great if you haven't seen them!

Food

Solution A: Give an active use.

The troubling fact about rations in my game is that they're cheap and trivially acquired for any party that's gone on at least one adventure. As long as you're not on a long long road trip through the uncharted wilderness (a situation that's literally never come up in my game in over half a decade), they're not an interesting resource drain.

So I flipped it from a drain to an actively used resource.

There are two main uses for rations in my game:
- Heal in a dungeon
- Heal fast overnight

My players think about food a lot, and track it individually. It's the primary healing mechanic so of course it's important!
This is even before the new cooking subsystem (coming soon...) which has made at least one player start tracking Standard Rations in close detail.

In practice this means that rations are a dungeon crawl resource replenished between delves. Run out of rations mid-crawl and you run out of easy healing, spend rations on the surface to get back down there as soon as possible.

Food tracking: SOLVED!!



Light

Solution B: Procedural tracking.

Players gain no advantage from remembering to track light sources.
That's the simple fact. Even if they're not doing it maliciously, the only reason for a player to track light is out of a sense of fairness.
So as with anything that sucks for the player, it's up to the DM to make sure it's enforced!

Trouble is, tracking light is kind of boring overhead and takes up valuable mental load.

My solution, courtesy of a primordial version of Necropraxis' Hazard System, is to track light on the encounter roll.










Torches burn out after two Torch Burnout results.
Lanterns burn out after four Lantern Burnout results.

The main advantage of this, for me, is that it becomes part of the normal procedure of play. 
It's not extra mental overhead to track, it's part of primary dungeon timer mechanic - random encounters.
This also introduces a level of randomness to light sources which I think works. Torches don't all last exactly an hour, fire isn't quite so predictable.

Light tracking: SOLVED!!



Ammo

Solution C: Ignore it

"Hey what? I thought this was meant to be solutions!" I hear you say.
Ignoring it is a solution my friend. Tracking normal ammo is the worst.
It feels like it should be important, but in practice it's really not.
It feels like it should be interesting to run out of ammo, but in practice it's not either. You just stab instead, or get creative with random junk in your inventory.

My players simply don't make that many ranged attacks - they avoid combat if possible, shooting into melee has a high risk of hitting a friend, and most of them have firearms that take too long to reload mid-fight.
I even tracked ammo with a Usage Die for a few years and nobody ever got low enough on ammo for it to matter. C'est le jeu.

So - just ignore it. A few ranged attacks per session isn't enough to worry about really.
Having a quiver or ammo bag or whatever has an encumbrance penalty, so there's a small but notable downside to having a ranged weapon already. It's fine.

Ammo tracking: IGNORED!!


Solutions

So there you have it - three different ways to solve resource tracking.

A: Give it an active use.
Make it important enough to track actively, just like potions and spells and HP and all the rest.

B: Procedural tracking.
Track it through a game mechanic, ideally rolling it into some other procedural thing you already do.

C: Ignore it.
If there's never any real risk of it running out, just don't bother.




Ammo 2: Bonus Spitballing

In writing this I was wondering if there was a better solution to ammunition.
Ignoring it is a fine solution but inherently fairly unsatisfying when you could be the first person to come up with a Rad New OSR Mechanic.

So there are two other options if I want to stop ignoring ammo - give it an active use, or procedural tracking.


A: Active use would be the obvious one. Rather than spend an ammo to make a ranged attack, why not spend an ammo to give that ranged attack a boost?
So like:
Bow - Rapid Fire - Spend an ammo to roll damage twice and take the best.
Gun - Overcharge Round - Spend an ammo to deal exploding damage on evens.

But then this could be covered by magic ammo and trick arrows and such. Just give them the option to buy Overload Cartridges or Dum-Dum Arrows and they'll track them religiously.
Plus I already use Gambits for doing cool stuff with mundane attacks, making this concept unnecessary.


B: Procedural Tracking is the other side of the coin. Perhaps roll ammo depletion into the attack roll.
If rolling a 1 on an attack roll means you've run out of ammo, that works out to an average of 20 arrows per quiver which is bang on.
But then you run the risk of a real dumb situation where your first shot from a fresh quiver is also your last.

You could give each ranged weapon 3 Ammo Boxes and a Depletion Range, so a quiver of arrows checks off an Ammo Box on an attack roll of 1-3 and a bag of sling bullets only checks off an Ammo Box on a 1.

I'd definitely use this myself, only it doesn't solve the initial point that my players just don't make that many ranged attacks! 



Encumbrance

A final note on encumbrance - writing this post has made me realise just how important encumbrance is as a limitation for mundane items like these.

There's no real limit to how much food, light and ammo a party can carry in the overworld. Any party that can afford a cart, a barrel of iron rations, and a pile of torches can park up next to a dungeon entrance and be set for weeks of delving.

The only limit is how much you're going to take into the dungeon with you. 
Are you going to be slow and prepared? Or are you going to travel fast and light? If you're wearing heavy armour are you willing to slow yourself further with bags of rations and jars of lamp oil?

Being slow means you face more encounter checks, so the feedback loop of resources-encumbrance-encounters is important if you want mundane resources to be an important choice.

Which is to say - if you handwave encumbrance and/or don't use random encounters there's no point tracking mundane resources. 
It seems obvious when I say it like that.

14 comments:

  1. This seems like a really useful post. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Food tracking looks AWESOME. Should Halflings be able to benefit from four, not two meals per day? I'm thinking breakfast and elevensies. The extra healing explains why the little bastards are so hard to put down.

    Also, do you remember this post on serving black pudding and basilisk stew?

    https://coinsandscrolls.blogspot.com/2017/07/monster-menu-all-part-1-eating-ad.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Eating monsters is totally the next bandwagon jump I'm going for ;)
      Building on top of this which is itself building on top of the monster menu-all:
      http://throneofsalt.blogspot.com/2018/07/unified-food-theory.html
      Halflings will be covered by making them naturally better cooks, so the food will heal more!

      And yea so the rule for mid-day healing is:
      Spend a 10 minute Turn and a ration to heal 1d6 HP.

      Halflings being able to eat as many rations as they want to heal Xd6 HP would be hilarious and fitting!

      Delete
  3. This is an absolutely excellent post, one that everyone in the OSR needs to read, or at least hear exists. Also, good suggestion on tracking ammo. I recently made a new setting based in the modern world, so when I gave the players guns, I just assumed that they would be smart enough to go buy and carry ammo and stopped keeping track of it, and it has worked wonders for me. So I'm glad to see someone else came to that conclusion. Anyway, good post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Share away my dude!

      So yea I think the only interesting thing about ammo, in a movie or something, is when the character runs out.
      click click "oh shit I'm out of ammo what do I do now?!"

      It's interesting because suddenly the character suddenly has limited options and the stakes are raised - can he escape without the capacity to kill? Where will he get another gun or ammo???

      But that's not interesting in D&D because you've already got SO MANY other options that not being able to shoot is just... fine ok I'll attack in some other way no worries.
      Besides the fact that my players don't shoot enough for it to matter, even if they did run out it wouldn't be a big deal.

      So yea, good choices all round for both of us!

      Delete
  4. Thanks again for your post. It proved inspiring, but not like I thought it would:
    http://thethingswedoforxp.blogspot.com/2018/08/get-them-to-ration-at-least-three-meals.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hahaha this is amazing! Halflings are dangerous, man.
      How come you've got such a limit on full meals? Are HP totals in GLOG so small that healing 1d6 hp is a big deal?

      Delete
    2. 1d6+level, thank you very much ;) And it was a spur of the moment thing. I didn't want to muscle in on the healing effect of a good night's sleep, and I like the idea of some hurt from one day carrying over the next (in other words, I dislike massive deadly combat-sleep-rinse&repeat). You're right that this will need tweakage for 5th edition where hit point totals are bigger than in GLOG.

      Delete
    3. Yea fair enough!
      I square that circle by making rations much less efficient as a healing method if eaten in the day.

      Take a Break:
      Spend a ration and ten minutes to heal 1d6 HP.

      Overnight Healing:
      If you eat a ration and have a warm dry place to sleep you heal up to the next bracket of half, full, or full+1d6 HP.

      Also I consider HP to be your luck and skill and death-avoidance, hence the Death & Dismemberment subsystem, so I don't have a problem with fast-ish healing!

      Delete
  5. Have you seen this GLOGgy ration solution? It's directly adjacent to yours. https://github.com/valzi/villagefolk/wiki/Healing_Bacon

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not surprising, as I got eat-to-heal from Arnold's blog way back when!
      I can't imagine someone spending an hour for lunch for a mere 1d6+level HP, that's 6 wandering monster checks! What happens when you're inevitably interrupted?

      Delete
  6. A slight modification to procedural tracking of ammunition: the depletion result is to reduce your /damage die/ to the next lower, with the explanation being that you've used up your best arrows/good powder, and now the ones left aren't quite as good. Buying new ammo tops you back up to the normal damage.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's interesting! Certainly more interesting than standard.

      Delete